IBC BELIZE: DEFEATS MIGHTY US SEC
Belize Defeats US SEC
Belize Court Makes Landmark Decision Protecting Offshore Privacy
Belize City, Friday, January 20, 1995 - NY Times.
In a landmark decision asserting Belize's sovereignty as an
offshore financial jurisdiction, the Supreme Court of Belize upheld the country's
confidentiality laws by revoking a previous court order set in motion by the Securities
and Exchange Commission of the United States requesting that confidential documents,
belonging to Swiss Trade and Commerce Trust, Ltd., be handed over to them.
In the case, Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) vs. Swiss Trade and Commerce Trust, Ltd.,
Banner Fund International, Lloyd Winburn et al, Supreme Court Justice Troadio Gonzalez ruled that
documents held by the Belize court belonging to Swiss Trade and sought by the SEC, be immediately
returned to Swiss Trade and Commerce Trust, Ltd.
Lawyers for Swiss Trade said that what this means for Belize is that this aspect of
confidentiality, which is an important feature of the offshore industry, has been upheld.
"What this means is that any party who seeks to destroy the concept of confidentiality would
have to contend with our system, which has demonstrated its ability to uphold the relevant laws,"
Attorney Oscar Sabido said.
The decision is expected to have major international repercussions as the world financial community
looks to Belize and its new offshore services industry. "It is certainly a shot in the arm of the
offshore industry because of the fact that it is an industry which is just beginning," Sabido said.
A country's ability to assert its sovereignty without the interference of outside forces is a major
deciding factor in choosing a place to invest and protect personal property.
When asked for his comment related to the decision, Lloyd Winburn, Director of Swiss Trade &
Commerce Trust, Ltd., in Belize, stated, "The Court's decision confirms our reasons for
establishing our company in Belize originally. The Confidentiality Law has been tested and
found to be not lacking clarity and strength. Any other ruling by the Court would have sent a signal
throughout the financial world that Belize could not be trusted to protect assets, provide
confidentiality of transactions or otherwise serve the needs of those who seek to do business away
"From their home jurisdiction."
The decision clearly shows that the SEC stepped out of bounds in trying to obtain confidential
information, the matter having been urged on both sides by learned Queen's Council.
The case arose after the SEC [bureaucrats] appeared at Swiss Trade's office on March 3, 1994 with
the expectation that they would be able to just take the files and leave the country with them, with no
regard whatever to Belizean law. The quick reaction of company employees prevented any further disregard
for the law on the part of the SEC [terrocrats] and their Belizean lawyer, Eamon Courtenay, who
previously had been the lawyer for Swiss Trade.